In Found Drowned Laurie Glenn Norris, already an established author of local historical non-fiction, tries her hand at fiction that is based on true historical events. Which, without a doubt, is a sure way to snag my interest.
In the beginning of Found Drowned a young woman is spotted by two boys, washed up on a beach in Prince Edward Island. While the citizens of Cape Traverse try to determine who this girl is and what happened to her, an alternate narrative takes us back to the life of Mary Harney, a 17-year-old girl from Rockley, Nova Scotia.
Found Drowned is the author’s attempt “to resurrect the life and times of Mary Harney, a young woman from Cumberland County, Nova Scotia, who disappeared without a trace in 1877, and who has been, for over a century, remembered only in the context of a ghost story.”
Laurie Glenn Norris does an excellent job bringing the people and places of the late 19th century to life. I was mesmerized by the story and the historical detail; attitudes and beliefs, judicial and forensic procedures, popular literature and magazines, as well as the daily grind.
Mary lived on a small farm with her parents and younger siblings, paternal grandmother and great-uncle. Her great-uncle John was nice, but she could have done without the harsh words and judgments she often got from her grandmother. And as she got older, her alcoholic father became someone she tried to avoid at all costs.
Before her mother’s illness the family had taken a trip to visit Mary’s maternal grandparents and aunt, and Mary continued to look back on that trip with longing.
Mary thought that Beatrice had the most interesting things. A Singer sewing machine that always smelled of the oil she doused it with, cardboard slides of side-by-side photographs that became one picture when you looked at them through a fancy viewer, and all the latest books and magazines. Along with ‘Godey’s’ she had both the ‘Canadian Illustrated News’ and the ‘London Illustrated News’ delivered by mail twice a month. And at the moment she was reading a new book just purchased from a Halifax bookstore. It was a collection of short stories entitled “Doctor Ox”, written by a man called Jules Verne. Best of all, she’d been reading “The Woman in White”, by Wilke Collins, aloud in the library every evening once Little Helen and Harry were put to bed. Grandpa called it trash but Mary, Ann, and Helen hung on every word.
Not too far in the future, over on the island, Dr. Jarvis is summoned to the Bell Farm where the dead body is waiting for an autopsy. The autopsy is described in a surprising amount of detail, as is the legal proceedings required under these circumstances. The police investigation is not carried out as well as it might have been (partly because assumptions are made about the deceased), and a Halifax detective has to be called in for a re-investigation. Which, for readers, makes the story even more interesting. But for Gilbert Bell, it means more time spent away from his daily farming duties. And time spent keeping his sons away from the irresistible goings-on.
The girl’s greenish-white skin became pink in the light of the sunset streaming through the cobwebs of the barn’s tiny west window. Jarvis cut, then tore, the right side of her jacket and its underarm along the seam. He slid it off the body, then did the same with the shirtwaist and chemise. Gilbert folded the sodden clothes and placed them in a neat pile on the floor.
The door handle rattled. “Pa, let us in.”
The case is brought to court with the gathered evidence and witnesses for and against the accused. But as we know, this has remained an unsolved crime.
“Well , gentlemen, what are your thoughts?” Oxley asked as he moved his chair closer to the table. It was six-thirty and the four justices were just settling down to supper back at the hotel. They had the dining room to themselves to discuss the hearing and come to a decision.
The reader is left to determine what happened to poor Mary Harney. I thought I would find this frustrating, but Glenn Norris tells such a good story that I found the end deeply satisfying. I was just sad it was over.
At the back of the book, Laurie Glenn Norris lists the newspaper articles she was able to find about Mary Harney’s disappearance, around which she built Mary’s story.
Rockley’s Screaming Ghost: The Mary Harney Mystery: Guest Post at Field Notes
Advance praise from Carol Bruneau (“exposes the underbelly of rural life”), Linda Moore (“drawn with compelling nineteenth-century detail”), Steven Laffoley (“wonderfully mesmerizing tale”), and Linda Little (“skilfully entangles our assumptions with the facts”).
Haunted Girl: Esther Cox and the Great Amherst Mystery (non-fiction) also sounds like a thrilling read.
Thank you to Nimbus Publishing for sending me a copy of this book!
19 thoughts on “Found Drowned by Laurie Glenn Norris”
Unsolved crimes make for intriguing fiction, I think. Lots of room for speculation.
Looks to be right up my street. I wonder how much of a distribution it’ll get down here in the states . . .
That’s a good question… You can always get in touch with the publisher! https://nimbus.ca/
Sounds like interesting reading. I’ve never heard the Mary Harney story so this will be an education too!
I’m currently reading the exceptionally researched Celtic Knot by Ann Shortell, about the real-life 1868 assassination of Thomas D’Arcy McGee.
I had never heard about Mary Harney before, either. Which makes me wonder what other stories are out there I don’t know about yet… (and it’s in your neck of the woods!)
Celtic Knot sounds tempting!
I adore fictionalised accounts of real life stories. This sounds very evocative.
They’re just so fascinating!
It’s really hard to get the balance of detail right without getting bogged down in all the research, I think. It sounds like this manages it really well.
I didn’t want to put it down!
This makes me think of an Alistair MacLeod ghost story. Does the advance praise come from blurbs? It – and your review – does make it sound very good!
Yes, the advance praise comes from blurbs inside the book. (But I have an ARC, so the blurbs could be somewhere else on the final copy.)
It does sounds like an AM ghost story! Maybe we will eventually come across something like it (if I ever get back to his story collection!).
This sounds fascinating. The right mix of eery and historical.
It’s a great read!
I love old-timey ghost stories, they’re even creepier than modern-day ones! I can’t remember where i just read about this book before your review-did you do another summary of it earlier? Gosh I have a terrible memory…
It wasn’t from me! But I’m glad to hear someone else out there is talking about it. 🙂
Sounds good! Is there actually a ghost?
There’s no ghost in the book. The book is based on the same events that the ghost story is based on.